Emmanuel Macron made quite an impression during a discussion on India–France academic partnerships that shifted into a broader tech debate. His comments were candid and unexpected and had many onlookers in shock.
France’s president questioned how social media platforms define what the term “freedom of speech” is. He believes that freedom of expression is meaningless when the systems governing what posted material can or cannot be seen aren’t subjected to public oversight.
The Line That Shocked the Room
A notable statement by Macron was his dismissal of the current public debate regarding how Internet users should have a right to communicate freely on their social media accounts. He claims that if an Internet user does not know or is not aware of how the platform they are viewing influences their thoughts or feelings, then the ability to communicate freely is irrelevant. Macron argued that the real issue is not speech itself but the invisible systems shaping what people see.
Algorithms at the Centre of the Debate
Macron shifted the focus from free speech to the systems guiding it. He questioned how platforms create, learn, and execute algorithms that affect billions of people (around the world). He said these algorithms – which no one can see – can be used to lead people toward extreme or polarised forms of content. He also expressed concern that, without accountability, societies will begin to exist in places where public discourse will be impacted by things that few have the ability to investigate.
He urged for transparent algorithms that could be tested and understood. Clarity is necessary to achieve trust in algorithms, according to him.
Also Read: From Slow Start to Six-Hitting Storm: Shivam Dube’s Knock That Changed the Game
A Democratic Concern, Not Just a Tech Issue
In his address, French President Emmanuel Macron emphasised social democratic challenges associated with these systems instead of just technological ones. He warned that opaque algorithms could have serious consequences for democratic systems.
Macron also requested policymakers to address opaque information flow on digital platforms, as they may result in greater division and bias. Furthermore, he cited concerns over the growth of racially and ethnically motivated hate on internet platforms, where algorithms are massively predominant.
His remarks align with broader European efforts to regulate digital platforms.
Why the Remarks Matter Now
Macron made this statement at an important moment. He was visiting India to discuss the future of academic and strategic partnerships between France and India but shifted gears in light of what was happening in the technology industry globally to comment on the larger debate in Europe regarding the regulation of the “digital duopolies”. This reaffirms current discussions taking place amongst lawmakers in Europe regarding the potential risks to our society with unregulated algorithms used by these large technology companies.
A Growing Global Conversation
Macron’s words may carry significant weight beyond the confines of a conference room. Around the globe, many governments are struggling to reconcile freedom of speech with accountability for the content that appears on social media sites.
Through his candid manner of speaking, he ensured that his views got spread quickly. Regardless of whether people agree with him or disagree with him, his comments have raised an argument about a crucial issue in today’s digital environment:
Since algorithms are determining how we communicate today, who is going to be responsible for creating those algorithms?
This question could have a lasting impact on what happens next for democracy around the world in an increasingly interconnected world.
Also Read: AI Summit India: Galgotias University Asked to Vacate Stall After Robot Controversy
